In an earlier post, I wrote about the decision of Lambourne v Marrable and, naturally, it was a particularly interesting case to discuss further in a recent episode of The Heir Waves podcast. So, here it is! In this episode, Caite & Michele are joined by a special guest, Dr Pip Coore of Hemmant’s List, and discuss…
Category: costs
Disentitling Declarations: statutory declaration about conduct, provision ordered in FPA (Qld)
The topic of statutory declarations being used in estate planning has been ongoing and [almost fiercely!] debated among succession lawyers. Litigators and planners both love them, but for very, very different reasons. In fact, it was a topic of conversation between Caite and I on The Heir Waves podcast here. In the case of Hartley…
Super Settled: High Court confirmation that Reg 6.17A SIS don’t apply to SMSFs
The long embattled question of whether Regulation 6.17A of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“SISR”) applies to SMSFs has finally been answered. For those playing at home, Reg 6.17A of the SISR sets out the standards of which regulated super funds are to pay a member’s superannuation benefits out when they pass away….
Elder Abuse = Disentitling Conduct: FPA by adult daughter dismissed with costs
It is no surprise to any of my colleagues in the succession world that this topic is of great interest to me. So, you can imagine my interest when I found this case. A few days ago, the New South Wales Supreme Court determined a matter that involved a family provision claim by an adult…
Conduct that disentitles: son’s application for FPA fails (QLD)
When someone contests a Will after being left out or not getting what they feel is their fair share, it’s more often than not that the surviving family want to suggest that that person’s conduct doesn’t entitlement to more, or sometimes anything. This is what us #lawnerds term as “disentitling conduct” in the context of…
Decision Impossible, Part 2: Appeal against disabled son’s FPA dismissed, with costs
Near the end of last year, I wrote a post about an FPA by a disabled son where provision was ordered in favour of that son to the detriment of the surviving widow of the deceased. This was, I feel, aptly described in the title as “Decision Impossible” as the effect of the order was…
Danger Zone: costs against plaintiff in FPA in small estate (NSW)
Family provision claims in small estates is an inherit danger zone for claimants and lawyers. The recent case of Wengdal v Rawnsley [2019] NSWSC 926 has demonstrated this again where Justice Hallen has ordered that the plaintiff’s claim be dismissed and the plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs on the ordinary basis. In this case, the deceased…
Catch and Release: Court considers when s33Z applies to a ‘purported’ Will (Qld)
Recently, the case of Saltmer v Rennick Lawyers Pty Ltd [2018] QSC 307 was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland in Townsville where the Court was called upon to question of costs in a situation where a deceased person’s family member requested a copy of a document held by a Solicitor that the family…
Wife support: FPA by widow dismissed with costs (NSW)
It is a suggestion that arises throughout many estate disputes that the claim of a widow on an estate should be paramount to those of other family member who survive the deceased person. However, as each case is determined on it’s merits, this is not always the case. Yesterday, the Supreme Court of New South Wales…
Dare to Care: Close personal relationship in FPA (NSW)
Many people would have a different view of exactly what a “close personal relationship” may look like. In New South Wales Family Provision law, their collection of people who may make a claim on an estate further further provision is much wider than that of Queensland. Under section 57(1)(f) of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW),…
Escaping the Nest: Abandoning a right to reside and FPA 15 years out of time
Recently, the NSW Supreme Court determined a slightly unusual coupling of issues; a construction matter as to a right to reside conditional upon payment of expenses alongside a family provision claim over 15 years out of time. The recent case of Estate of George Roby, deceased [2017] NSWSC 265 involved the estate of the late George Roby who passed…
“There is no one alive who is you-er than you!” – Imposter Testator and the Supreme Court
“There is no one alive who is you-er than you!” – Dr Seuss In an odd case, Chief Justice Catherine Holmes was called upon to determine an application of probate in solemn form with a side order of an imposter claim. In the case Martin Terrence Farrell v Warren Elbridge Boston [2016] QSC 278, the Applicant, Martin…
FPA x2: Grandson vs Daughter – Close Personal Relationship
This month, the Supreme Court of New South Wales, determined a family provision claim by a self-sufficient adult daughter and an adult grandson. In the case of Re Filomena Rodi, deceased [2016] NSWSC 1696, the deceased was survived by four children, 2 daughters and 2 sons, and had left her estate to them equally….
An offer is an offer, no matter how small?: Costs in FPA after parentage test negative. Dismiss/Discontinue?
Recently, the Supreme Court of New South Wales was tasked with determining whether the Court should dismiss or discontinue proceedings following the plaintiff’s parentage testing resulting in him not being the deceased’s child and therefore not an eligible person to make a claim. In the matter of Patterson v Scott [2016] NSWSC 1477 the Court heard that the plaintiff had commenced a family provision…
Executor’s duty and what to do with that additional informal document
In their last days, people can often have cause to consider additional wishes they want to record somewhere as they consider what means most to them. Unfortunately, sometimes recording these wishes can become problematic for the executors and family left behind. Here’s a good example: I recently read the case of Re Mangan [2016] VSC 480…
Family Provision and 30 years of estrangement, continued…
In my earlier post about the case of Wright v Wright where a family provision claim by estranged children was successful, the Court was to hear the parties arguments relating to how the legal costs of the claim should be paid (i.e. from the estate and which beneficiaries would pay etc. In the first judgement, the Court felt that it…