Site icon Michele Davis

Extension of time application dismissed – 11 months out of time

timeYesterday, the Supreme Court of Tasmania determined an application for extension of time in a family provision matter.

The case of Nicholas v Tubb [2016] TASSC 53 was an application made by the 4 adult children of the deceased testatrix.

The time to bring the application expired on 27 June 2015 and the originating application was filed on 19 May 2016. This was almost 11 months out of time.

By way of background, the Court outlined the following:

The Court, dismissing the claim, was not satisfied that there was good reason to defer obtaining legal advice between October 2014 and August 2015.

The Court also noted that Brodi, during the period of delay, had made improvements to the farm property which could not be ignored.

The Court said, at paragraph 33:

Notwithstanding that the first applicant has a viable claim, having regard to the period of delay, the absence of a reasonable explanation for it and the ongoing prejudice suffered by Brodi Nicholas as a result of the delay, I am left unpersuaded that the justice of the case rests with giving the first applicant a favourable exercise of the discretion to extend time.

Whilst clearly the children had relied upon one of them obtaining the requisite advice, the Court wasn’t satisfied that that was good enough reason for a delay.  The Court said that “there was no evidence of any steps taken by the second applicant to keep herself informed of progress and to push the matter ahead” (at paragraph 34). Whilst the second applicant had attributed medical problems to her inability to drive, the Court said that still would not have prevented her from taking an active interest in the progress of the matter and that her failure to take that interest, contributed to the delay and the prejudice that has been suffered by Brodi and WOULD be suffered by him should the application for time be granted (paragraph 34).

You can read the case here.

This case represents a useful reminder that tardiness in seeking legal advice as to your right and subsequently bringing about and progressing that action are not sufficient to obtain an extension; nor is it sufficient to rely upon another to do so.

Exit mobile version